500 Kinzie Island CT, SANIBEL, FL 33957

$1,895,000

One of Sanibel Island’s treasured secrets is Kinzie Island, a private, gated waterfront enclave that feels worlds apart from the everyday. This gated community of only 22 residences is adjacent to Sanibel’s renowned shelling beaches and defined by serene canals, manicured grounds, and an unmistakable sense of privacy and prestige.… Read More In this oasis, on over a half-acre lot, is an exceptional canal-front home offering an effortless blend of relaxed island living and understated luxury. Lush tropical landscaping with stately palms add to the mystic of the property. Outdoor living unfolds across multiple levels. Sip morning coffee on the front balcony, host breezy afternoons or sunset dinners on the spacious, back lanai featuring a striking tongue & groove ceiling, and overlooking the canal, or retreat to the third-floor sundeck where panoramic skies, sunshine, and salt air set the tone for island life & amazing sunsets. Inside, the residence is warm, inviting, and thoughtfully done in an eclectic blend of old world charm and contemporary design that speaks to both daily living and entertaining. The kitchen, functional and stylish, features a high-end gas range, wine cooler, and an expansive center island with seating, creating a natural gathering space for casual mornings or lively evenings with friends. It opens to an opulent dining area enhanced by a striking fireplace, adding ambiance and comfort for intimate dinners and special occasions alike. An expansive living room and sitting room provide ample space for family and guests. Two primary bedrooms, one on the main level, and one on the third floor, add accessibility and convenience. Surprising bonus space will delight along with a 3 car garage perfect for all your toys. A private dock with boat lift places open water right in your backyard, perfect for days spent cruising the Gulf, fishing at sunset, or exploring the area’s natural beauty by boat. Kinzie Island provides an unmatched island lifestyle where residents enjoy access to a heated lap pool, tennis, pickleball, and bocce courts, and more. Neighbors are convivial and welcoming. Just across the street, the private beach club provides easy access to the Gulf, complete with a fitness center, restrooms, beach storage, and a dedicated walkway to the sandy beach. This home presents a rare opportunity to experience an intimate, waterfront lifestyle defined by privacy, natural beauty, and the magic of Sanibel Island. Kinzie Island properties are limited, making this offering as exceptional as the setting itself. Read Less

Listing courtesy of Kingfisher Real Estate, Inc..

Listing Snapshot

Days Online

Last Updated

May 13, 2026

Property Type

Single Family Residence

Beds

Full Baths

Square Ft.

3,807

Lot Size

0.59 Acres

Year Built

1995

MLS Number

2026020694

30 Days Snapshot Of 33957

$1.61M

+2%

(avg) sold price

-21%

homes sold

172

-3%

(avg) days on market

Snapshot

Area Map

Additional Details

Appliances & Equipment

"Dishwasher", "Disposal", "Dryer", "Microwave", "Range", "Refrigerator/Icemaker", "Washer", "Wine Cooler"

Building

Built in 1995, Building area units: Square Feet, Living area: 2,696, Construction materials: "Concrete Block", "Wood Frame", "Stucco", Other structures: "Tennis Court(s)", 3 total stories

Community

"Pool", "Fitness Center", "Tennis Court(s)", "Gated"

Cooling

"Ceiling Fan(s)", "Central Electric"

Doors

"French Doors"

Exterior Features

"Boat Dock Private", "Boat Lift", "Balcony", "Open Porch/Lanai", "Screened Lanai/Porch"

Floors

"Tile"

Garage

3 spaces

Heating

"Central Electric"

Home Owner's Association

Association fee: $12,000

Interior Features

Furnished: Partially, "Coffered Ceiling(s)", "Fireplace", "Foyer", "French Doors", "Laundry Tub", "Volume Ceiling", "Walk-In Closet(s)", "Window Coverings"

Laundry

"Laundry in Residence", "Laundry Tub"

Lot

0.59 acres, 25,700 square feet, "Irregular Lot", "Oversize"

Parking

3 covered spaces, 3 total parkings, "Attached"

Pets Policy

Pets allowed: "Yes"

Pool

"Community"

Property

"Canal Front", "Navigable", Patio and porch features: "Deck", "Patio", "Canal", "Landscaped Area", "Mangroves", "Partial Gulf"

Roof

"Metal"

Security Features

"Gated Community"

Taxes

Tax annual amount: $17,331, Tax year: 2025

Windows

"Window Coverings"

Find The Perfect Home

'VIP' Listing Search

Whenever a listing hits the market that matches your criteria you will be immediately notified.

Join The List

Mortgage Calculator

Selling price

Down payment

Term (years)

Interest rate (%)

Monthly Payment

500 Kinzie Island CT

'VIP' Listing Search

Schools In The Area

Similar Listings

Find My Dream Home

1. Neighborhoods

2. Home Type

3. Send